This, then, was what his mother and Kate meant--this--the greatest of all calamities--the overthrow of a MAN.
For the hundredth time he turned his wandering search-light into his own heart.

The salient features of his own short career passed in review: the fluttering of the torn card as it fell to the floor; the sharp crack of Willits's pistol; the cold, harsh tones of his father's voice when he ordered him from the house; Kate's dear eyes streaming with tears and her uplifted hands--their repellent palms turned toward him as she sobbed--"Go away--my heart is broken!" And then the refrain of the poem which of late had haunted him night and day: "Disaster following fast and following faster, Till his song one burden bore," and then the full, rich tones of Poe's voice pleading with his Maker: "Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us." Yes:--Disaster had followed fast and faster.

But why had it followed him?
What had he done to bring all this misery upon himself?
How could he have acted differently?
Wherein had he broken any law he had been taught to uphold, and if he had broken it why should he not be forgiven?
Why, too, had Kate turned away from him?
He had promised her never to drink again; he had kept that promise, and, God helping him, he would always keep it, as would any other man who had seen what he had just seen to-night.

Perhaps he had trespassed in the duel, and yet he would fight Willits again were the circumstances the same, and in this view Uncle George upheld him.

But suppose he had trespassed--suppose he had committed a fault--as his father declared--why should not Kate forgive him?
She had forgiven Willits, who was drunk, and yet she would not forgive him, who had not allowed a drop to pass his lips since he had given her his promise.