That Hayle betrayed them I have not the least doubt, it seems consistent with his character, but where they obtained the jewels, that are practically the keystones to the whole affair, I have no more notion than you.

They may have been honestly come by, or they may not.

So far as the present case is concerned that fact is immaterial.

There is still, however, one vital point we have to consider.

If the gems in question belong equally to the three men, each is entitled to his proper share, either of the stones or of the amounts realized by the sale.