Mr.Cleave added that he made experiments "for five nights running" before seeing the lady.

The young lady's letter of 19th January, 1886, is also produced (postmark, Portsmouth, 20th January).

But the lady mentions her _first_ vision of Mr.Cleave as on last _Tuesday_ (not Friday), and her second, while she was alone with her little brother, at supper on Monday.

"I was so frightened that I nearly fainted." These are all young people.

It may be said that all five were concerned in a complicated hoax on Mr.Gurney.