[A Leap in the Dark by A.V. Dicey]@TWC D-Link book
A Leap in the Dark

CHAPTER II
128/140

197, 198 _post_.
[67] These Restrictions, or safeguards, deprive Ireland of powers in fact possessed by the Legislature of any self-governing colony, and I believe by the Isle of Man or Jersey.

[Compare the Home Rule Bill 1893, clause 3, sub-clause (3) (p.

197, _post_,) as it appears in the original Bill, with the same clause as amended by the House of Commons and sent up to the House of Lords.

The original clause forbids the Irish Parliament to make any law in respect (_inter alia_) of 'naval or military forces or the defence of the realm.' The clause as amended by the House of Commons forbids the Irish Parliament to make any law in respect of '(3.) Navy, Army, Militia, Volunteers, and any other military forces, or the defence of the realm, or forts, or permanent military camps, magazines, arsenals, dockyards, and other needful buildings, or any places purchased for the erection thereof.' In 1893, Unionists and Gladstonians alike were determined that on no pretence whatever should an Irish Parliament be allowed to raise an Irish army, even of volunteers.

The very name of 'volunteers,' and the history of 1780-82, explain and justify their prudence.
[68] Clause 4, sub-clause (1) to (4).
[69] For the details of the Restrictions contained in clauses 3 and 4 the reader should study carefully the terms of the Bill itself.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books