[The Republic by Plato]@TWC D-Link book
The Republic

INTRODUCTION AND ANALYSIS
405/474

The movement of a body of men can never have the pliancy or facility of a single man; the freedom of the individual, which is always limited, becomes still more straitened when transferred to a nation.

The powers of action and feeling are necessarily weaker and more balanced when they are diffused through a community; whence arises the often discussed question, 'Can a nation, like an individual, have a conscience ?' We hesitate to say that the characters of nations are nothing more than the sum of the characters of the individuals who compose them; because there may be tendencies in individuals which react upon one another.

A whole nation may be wiser than any one man in it; or may be animated by some common opinion or feeling which could not equally have affected the mind of a single person, or may have been inspired by a leader of genius to perform acts more than human.

Plato does not appear to have analysed the complications which arise out of the collective action of mankind.
Neither is he capable of seeing that analogies, though specious as arguments, may often have no foundation in fact, or of distinguishing between what is intelligible or vividly present to the mind, and what is true.

In this respect he is far below Aristotle, who is comparatively seldom imposed upon by false analogies.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books