[Logic by Carveth Read]@TWC D-Link bookLogic CHAPTER V 21/24
Propositions not thus qualified are called Pure. Modal propositions have had a long and eventful history, but they have not been found tractable by the resources of ordinary Logic, and are now generally neglected by the authors of text-books.
No doubt such propositions are the commonest in ordinary discourse, and in some rough way we combine them and draw inferences from them.
It is understood that a combination of assertory or of apodeictic premises may warrant an assertory or an apodeictic conclusion; but that if we combine either of these with a problematic premise our conclusion becomes problematic; whilst the combination of two problematic premises gives a conclusion less certain than either.
But if we ask 'How much less certain ?' there is no answer.
That the modality of a conclusion follows the less certain of the premises combined, is inadequate for scientific guidance; so that, as Deductive Logic can get no farther than this, it has abandoned the discussion of Modals.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|