There was something true in both conjectures; for although Edward's mind acquitted him of the crime with which he was charged, yet a hasty review of his own conduct convinced him he might have great difficulty in establishing his innocence to the satisfaction of others.
'It is a very painful part of this painful business,' said Major Melville, after a pause, 'that, under so grave a charge, I must necessarily request to see such papers as you have on your person.' 'You shall, sir, without reserve,' said Edward, throwing his pocket-book and memorandums upon the table; 'there is but one with which I could wish you would dispense.' 'I am afraid, Mr.Waverley, I can indulge you with no reservation.' 'You shall see it then, sir; and as it can be of no service, I beg it may be returned.' He took from his bosom the lines he had that morning received, and presented them with the envelope.

The Major perused them in silence, and directed his clerk to make a copy of them.

He then wrapped the copy in the envelope, and placing it on the table before him, returned the original to Waverley, with an air of melancholy gravity.
After indulging the prisoner, for such our hero must now be considered, with what he thought a reasonable time for reflection, Major Melville resumed his examination, premising, that as Mr.Waverley seemed to object to general questions, his interrogatories should be as specific as his information permitted.

He then proceeded in his investigation, dictating, as he went on, the import of the questions and answers to the amanuensis, by whom it was written down.
Did Mr.Waverley know one Humphry Houghton, a non-commissioned officer in Gardiner's dragoons ?' 'Certainly; he was sergeant of my troop, and son of a tenant of my uncle.' 'Exactly--and had a considerable share of your confidence, and an influence among his comrades ?' 'I had never occasion to repose confidence in a person of his description,' answered Waverley.

'I favoured Sergeant Houghton as a clever, active young fellow, and I believe his fellow soldiers respected him accordingly.' 'But you used through this man,' answered Major Melville, 'to communicate with such of your troop as were recruited upon Waverley-Honour ?' 'Certainly; the poor fellows, finding themselves in a regiment chiefly composed of Scotch or Irish, looked up to me in any of their little distresses, and naturally made their countryman, and sergeant, their spokesman on such occasions.' 'Sergeant Houghton's influence,' continued the Major, 'extended, then, particularly over those soldiers who followed you to the regiment from your uncle's estate ?' 'Surely;--but what is that to the present purpose ?' 'To that I am just coming, and I beseech your candid reply.