The newspaper sent was the "Manchester Examiner" for September 9th, 1861, containing a report of Mr.Fawcett's address given before Section D of the British Association, "On the method of Mr.Darwin in his treatise on the origin of species," in which the speaker showed that the "method of investigation pursued by Mr.Darwin in his treatise on the origin of species is in strict accordance with the principles of logic." The "A" of the letter (as published in Fawcett's Life) is the late Professor Williamson, who is reported to have said that "while he would not say that Mr.Darwin's book had caused him a loss of reputation, he was sure that it had not caused a gain." The reference to "B" is explained by the report of the late Dr.Lankester's speech in which he said, "The facts brought forward in support of the hypothesis had a very different value indeed from that of the hypothesis...A great naturalist, who was still a friend of Mr.Darwin, once said to him (Dr.Lankester), 'The mistake is, that Darwin has dealt with origin.

Why did he not put his facts before us, and let them rest ?'" Another speaker, the Rt.Hon.

J.R.

Napier, remarked: "I am going to speak closely to the question.

If the hypothesis is put forward to contradict facts, and the averments are contrary to the Word of God, I say that it is not a logical argument." At this point the chairman, Professor Babington, wisely interfered, on the ground that the meeting was a scientific one.), which I was very glad to see; and now I have to thank you sincerely for allowing me to see your MS.